2. ročník doktorandské filosofické konference

Ročník: 2025

Addressing Contemporary Issues in Ethics with Aristotle and Søren Kierkegaard: A Case Study on Sex-Robots to Prevent Child Abuse

Autor/ka: Cécilia Andree Monique Lombard, MPhil

St Patrick's Pontifical University, Maynooth, Ireland

Abstrakt

My claim in this presentation is that sex-robots would fundamentally be worsening the degeneration of pedophilia into child abuse, because it is a self-indulgence, despite technology’s ambivalent moral value. In the first part, I will provide a model of ethics that emphasizes self-work in order to develop morality, based on  Aristotle (1999, e. g. 1103a, 1170a) and Kierkegaard (1980, 35-6 and 129-38; 1987, 254-5). 

In the second part, I will use that model to provide an argument supported by empirical data for my claim in a case study on pedophilia and sex-robots. Following  Aristotle and Kierkegaard, I will suggest that child abuses happen from a lack of self-development and the orientation of an individual towards the satisfaction of wrong desires. Thus, the possibility of mediating abuses with artificial beings cannot offer a way to prevent child abuse in the long term, because it would only reinforce the attraction of wrong desires instead of helping one to be aware and work on themselves. 

This view seems to align with recent research highlighting the lack of evidence for a positive moral outcome on such therapeutic use (Devlin, 2018, 197/226).

Klíčová slova: Virtue Ethics, Existentialism, sex-robots, self-development, child abuse

Reference

  • Aristotle. (1999). The Nicomachean Ethics. Tr. T. Irwin, Second Edition. Hackett  Publishing Company, Inc. 
  • Devlin, K. (2018). Turned On: Science, Sex and Robots. Bloomsbury. Kindle edition. 
  • Chun, J. K. (1985). “The Relation to Education of Guilt and Conscience in the  Philosophy of Søren Kierkegaard and Martin Heidegger”. PhD diss., Columbia  University. University Microfilm International. 
  • Kierkegaard, S. (1987). Kierkegaard’s Writings IV: Either/Or, Part II. Tr. H. V. Hong  and E. H. Hong. Princeton University Press. 
  • Kierkegaard, S. (1980). Kierkegaard’s Writings VIII: The Concept of Anxiety. Tr. R.  Thomte and A. B. Anderson. Princeton University Press.